Most recent comments
Romjulen 2018
Camilla, 4 months, 3 weeks
Liveblogg nyttårsaften 2017
Tor, 1 year, 4 months
Jogging og blogging
Are, 2 years, 4 months
Liveblogg nyttårsaften 2016
Are, 2 years, 4 months
Reading in dark times
Are, 2 years, 6 months
Moldejazz 2016
Camilla, 2 years, 9 months
Karoline, 2 years, 10 months
Tor, 2 years, 11 months
Sony Smartwatch 3 review
Tor, 2 years, 11 months
Den årlige påske-kommentaren
Tor, 1 month, 1 week
50 book challenge
Camilla, 4 months, 3 weeks
Five years ago
Movie Narrative Charts

A tale of an unknown book

As a librarian, I know the helpless feeling of having someone asking for a book by its name and author, and still not finding it anywhere. In by far the most cases the lender remembers the title slightly (or completely) wrong, and this is what we politely try to tell them. But of course, once in a while the catalog itself is wrong or incomplete. It's not supposed to happen but, just like anything that's not supposed to happen, from time to time it does. And that makes us look very inept and somewhat stupid, especially after we've politely encouraged the lender to think just a little harder. In such cases, we correct the catalog and hope for it to be the last time.

I am of course also a book colletor on my spare time. I specialise in maps and atlases, and I do keep them all organised in a catalog, listing the basic bibliographic data. Not that I need to, because I know exactly where each one is at any given time. It's not so much about finding the books as it's about discovering more about them. Because finding out when and where each book is from is not always as easy as it sounds.

Sometimes they don't print the printing year. Maybe they just expected people to throw the map away and buy a new one after New Year's. So now, decades later, I must resort to carefully checking the ever-changing borders and place-names. Russian Alaska, Austro-Hungary, East Germany and so on. In most cases, this can be pinpointed down to a three or four year period. The greatest challenge still is extracting the publisher's name and other facts from foreign script books like Arabic and Chinese. But with the help of transcription tables, foreign friends and international library databases these exotic riddles are normally solved in the end. Obsolete languages are a bit harder. I'm still working‒or rather looking for help‒on pre-war Japanese and Ottoman Turkish title pages that I'm not sure today's average native speaker could just sit down and read.

But the most difficult one this far was, believe it or not, a German world atlas.

German isn't some obscure language from ages ago, it's practically the same as my native tongue Norwegian. Compared to Chinese it is, anyway. And (no surprise) Germany is, from a professional cataloger's point of view, heaven on Earth. In fact, I use a German search engine, the Karlsruhe catalog, to access British, American and other library inventories. It has such a neat, concise interface, and everything is there, exactly in its right place. That's why I was so surprised when I tried to look up my latest acquisition.

I picked up this marvelous old atlas in a Swiss second-hand-everything-store. (It was either this book, a Moon globe or a genuine Napoleon style hat, and every night I pray that I won't be faced with such a heart-breaking dilemma ever again.) Well, I don't regret my choice. The title is clear enough, the author as well. It's called

Professor Daniel Völter's Hand-Atlas der Erd-, Völker- und Staatenkunde
in 38 Karten.
Vierte, vermehrte und verbesserte Auflage.

(Professor Daniel Völter's Hand Atlas of Geography, Ethnography and Nations
comprising 38 Maps.
Fourth, extended and improved edition.)

Hand-Atlas is basically German for "home atlas", an atlas you keep at hand, as opposed to the Schul-Atlas designed for education and accompanied by a text book. This one's printed by Verlag von Conrad Weychardt in the small town Esslingen near Stuttgart. There is no printing year, but each map sheet is dated with its latest revision. These range from 1853 to 1863. Among the latest is the map of the US, which was at the time a rapidly changing nation at war with itself. The book is beautifully printed, very fine-lined for its time, with 38 magnificent hand-coloured maps of continents, nations and various commercial and natural aspects of the known world. Truly as much a piece of art as a reference work, as well as a historical document. I was especially curious to find out exactly when it was published, what with the varying dates on each page. But oddly, the book was nowhere to be found in any catalogs or databases. Even the German ones.

I considered the possibility that the maps were printed individually or as booklets, and issued to subscribers. This was often the case with larger works at this time, and it could have dodged the bibliographies. But a ten year period seemed quite unlikely, and the book has an original printer's binding, not the private binding that is so typical of these "partial" issues. It seems to have been published collected as one piece, in or shortly after 1863.

Africa in 1856, the same year David Livingstone completed the first trans-African journey by a white man. Most of the place-names of the interior are hearsay or guesswork. Note also the complete lack of information about the central rainforest areas.

After searching absolutely every catalog I could think of, I found only two entries for this title: The Bayerische Staatsbibliothek had a 1855 edition and the Universitätsbibliothek Bern had a fifth edition dated 1867. The 1855 edition was listed in several German publishing lists of the time, but I found none later than 1860. That is exceptionally few surviving copies, and mine was clearly none of these.

On the commercial market, all I found was a British antiquarian bookseller offering one map sheet from this book, the East Asia map. There was no information about which edition it came from.

I also found a few other books by professor Völter, he had published a historical atlas in the 1850s and a school atlas in several editions. But my book was still mysteriously missing from all lists.

Alaska was a Russian colony until the Americans simply bought it in 1867. At the time everybody was outraged at Secretary of State William Seward for spending $7 million on something like that. But just imagine a Cold War with this lineup.

But if you look everywhere, you will inevitably find something: Jürgen Esperhort's book Petermann's Planet seemed to be the authoritative work on the subject, and it contains a bibliography of German Hand-Atlases from 1800 to 1950. According to the index it included the Völter publications. I lent the book from Germany through the National Library, and after waiting a few weeks I could finally look up professor Völter to find a sizeable piece about his life and career. (He was born in 1814 and actually a priest-turned-scientist.) The book also contained a meticulous list of his geographical publications. The list appears to be assembled from library catalogs, and there doesn't seem to exist any authoritative list kept by Völter or his publishers.

Esperhorst's impressive bibliography lists a 4th edition of the Hand-Atlas published in 1855 (apparently, there are four known copies worldwide, with only one privately owned‒Frankly, that's hard to believe) and a 5th edition printed in 1867. According to Esperhorst, no copies of this fifth edition could be located. (Although the University Library of Bern lists one in their catalog, I haven't checked if it's physically there.) There is no mention whatsoever of a revised fourth edition published between these two. Finally, he shows a facsimile of sheet no. 18 (the Switzerland map) from the 4th edition. This differs in several ways from the same sheet in my atlas.

So, from what I can tell I am the owner of a (previously) unknown, undocumented book. Quite exciting. I tried contacting Mister Esperhorst, who requests updates, but the email address given in his book was defunct. So what do I do? I post the full story here, hoping that some day somebody else will be frantically googling the old professor Völter (also spelled Voelter) just like I did, and that the revised fourth edition will in the end make its way onto the record somewhere.

Until the 1870s, Turkey extended all the way to the Austrian border. The 300 years of Turkish presence is still evident in many aspects of Balkan culture.

To back it up and spread the word, I'll include the full atlas in PDF format here (I'm sorry the resolution isn't all it should be, but I don't have a wide selection of scanners in size A3 and upwards).

So please enjoy this old treasure‒It's one of a kind.
Camilla, Matteus, Are, Tor, Johannes, Jørgen likes this


Camilla,  15.06.11 09:29

How very, very, very cool. Your articles are steadily the best of the crop here, and this is no exception. Book history in mystery form to go with my morning coffee makes me really very happy.

The book looks lovely, as well. It would be interesting to see a scan with a slightly better resolution, mainly because I did the obvious thing and checked whether Molde was there (the old map equivalent of googling oneself, I suppose), only to find that while Christiansund was there, Molde did not appear to be. For a horrible moment, though, I thought Fræna was. I couldn't quite make out the writing. Scary. But for more general stuff that scan looks good to me. It certainly gives an idea of the book and what it looks like.

What a lovely way to start the day.

Are,  15.06.11 13:17


Anders K.,  15.06.11 18:16

The most fascinating thing about maps is how they contain innumerable levels of detail. Naurally, high resolution is a must for things like this. (In time, I'll find a way to photograph the whole thing. And all the other ones as well.)

Romsdals amt, 1853.

Molde is here, although placed a few miles too far west. Along with Christianssund it had enjoyed its city privileges for 111 years when this map was made, and at this time it was actually the largest city between Bergen and Trondheim.

But maps of this time often apply strange criteria for what places they list and not. Note, for example, that the miserable hamlet of Orskaug, containing at the time merely 800 degenerate souls (1), mostly cattle thieves and imbeciles, is prominently named. On the other hand, the area's commercial center, Ålesund (with close to 5,000 inhabitants (2), a hundred certified craftsmen (3) and an international port) is omitted. I have no idea who made that decision.
Jørgen likes this
Last edited by
Anders K., 16.06.11 12:19